The short answer

  • What an undertaking is. In SafeWork SA’s words, An Enforceable Undertaking (EU) is an alternative to court-imposed penalties with a higher expected investment into safety initiatives for the workplace, industry and community. It is available only for Category 2 and 3 offences, never Category 1 or industrial manslaughter, and it is not an admission of guilt.
  • What 25 agreements committed. About $7.8 million in minimum spending from June 2021 to September 2026. The median agreement is $207,233; the largest, by the Department of Human Services after a client’s death, is $1,386,145.
  • Where it goes. 71 per cent to benefits for workers and others, 14 per cent to industry, 13 per cent to the community and 2 per cent to SafeWork SA’s own costs.
  • What the register does not tell you. It publishes each signed agreement and any change to its terms. It does not say which agreements were completed, so the $12 million figure cannot be checked against it.

Exhibit A · from the source

The minimum-spend table in the Department for Education's 2024 enforceable undertaking: benefits to workers/others $412,680, industry $45,942, community $68,255, regulator costs $6,145, estimated total minimum spend $533,022
Cropped from page 26 (term 3.6, minimum spend) of the Department for Education’s signed enforceable undertaking, accepted 26 March 2024 after a fall at Urrbrae Agricultural High School in November 2020. Every agreement since 2021 carries a table in this form; we added up all 25. The outlines are ours. Back to the summary

Where the $7.8 million goes

Each agreement on SafeWork SA’s register since 2021 uses the same form. Work already done to fix the hazard, which the form calls rectifications, is reported near the front and does not count: the application guidelines say a term that only meets the law cannot be considered for the purpose of an undertaking. What counts is a minimum spend in four lines. Added across all 25:

  • Benefits to workers and others: $5,526,848 (71.1%)
  • Benefits to industry: $1,094,094 (14.1%)
  • Benefits to the community: $989,453 (12.7%)
  • SafeWork SA’s costs: $163,964 (2.1%)
Bars drawn to scale as shares of the $7,774,359 the four lines add to. From the term 3.6 table of each of the 25 agreements accepted from June 2021 to September 2026 on SafeWork SA’s register, read 16 November 2026. Our arithmetic; see the methodology.

In the agreements we read, “workers and others” is mostly the duty holder’s own site: new plant, training, safety staff, audits and software, plus support for the injured person. In the carpentry company agreement that SafeWork SA picked for its new case study, that meant a scissor lift, platform ladders, harnesses, first aid and heights training, and a part-time WHS manager after an apprentice fell through a stair void.

The money is concentrated. Three agreements make up 37 per cent of the total: the Department of Human Services ($1,386,145), Adelaide Brighton Cement ($876,545) and a mining contractor in 2022 ($627,000). Seven are under $100,000. Seven were accepted between June and December 2021 and three or four in each year since; four have been accepted in 2026, the latest from OneSteel Manufacturing, in administration since February 2025, for $417,880 after a worker was burned at the Whyalla pellet plant in August 2023.

The largest is the one to read. The Department of Human Services gave its undertaking in February 2025 over the death of a disability client in its care at Felixstow in April 2022, a Category 2 matter. Its minimum spend of $1,386,145 is, in the department’s words, in addition to the $8m+ already incurred by the Department in our response to this incident and in related improvements. A state department fined in court would be paying the state. Here the money has to go to named safety work, which is a real argument for the tool when the duty holder is the government.

What the community money buys

The community line, 13 per cent, is where the agreements stray furthest from the harm. SafeWork SA’s new list of suitable activities suggests sponsoring community events on WHS topics and funding community fundraising events, among other things. The agreements use that room:

  • OneSteel: psychological first aid training for local businesses and volunteers ($22,500) and equipment for the State Emergency Service ($10,000).
  • A concrete company in 2024: a hand-safety training package for five Men’s Sheds ($25,000).
  • Acciona in 2023: a $30,000 donation to Beyond Blue to promote its services to construction workers.
  • The case-study carpentry company: Industry Safety Rounds at a football club, now mostly a scoreboard.

Exhibit B · from the source

SafeWork SA notice varying term 3.4.1 of the Ruediger Constructions undertaking: the company will provide $60,000.00 to the football club for the purchase and installation of a permanent electronic scoreboard
Cropped from page 2 of SafeWork SA’s second notice of variation to term 3.4.1 of the undertaking accepted on 5 August 2025 (the PDF is dated 27 July 2026). The term’s minimum cost stays $65,000, with $5,000 for promotion; the agreement’s total is $373,120. The outlines are ours. Back to the summary

The variation moved both safety rounds to 2027 due to delays arising from third-party involvement, and the scoreboard will carry safety messages during them. None of these items is improper, and each requires invoices and evidence to be given to SafeWork SA. They are simply a long way from the fall, the burn or the death that started the matter.

Promises, not receipts

SafeWork SA’s release says the $12 million has been spent. What its register publishes for the 25 agreements since 2021 is this:

  • Signed agreement: 25 of 25
  • Regulator’s reasons for accepting it: 14 of 25
  • At least one notice varying its terms: 10 of 25
  • Notice that it was completed or released: 0 of 25
Counted from the links listed under each agreement on SafeWork SA’s enforceable undertakings register, read 16 November 2026. Bars to scale against 25.

The case study says SafeWork SA’s coordinator checks that each activity is done before an agreement is released, so the checking happens. It just is not published. The $7.8 million on the register is a floor of promises, made before the work; the release does not say whether its $12 million counts promises or verified spending, or whether it counts the rectifications the guidelines exclude.

How the sums compare with a fine

The release says duty holders must commit to expenditure expected to exceed the fine a court would impose. Two yardsticks are public. Safe Work Australia’s national data put the average financial penalty per successful prosecution in 2025 at $147,985, and 17 of the 25 agreements exceed it. SafeWork SA’s own judgements page lists 2026 fines up to $360,000, and eight agreements exceed that.

  • National average WHS penalty, 2025: $147,985
  • Median South Australian undertaking since 2021: $207,233
  • Largest South Australian fine listed for 2026: $360,000
  • Largest South Australian undertaking since 2021: $1,386,145
Bars drawn to scale against $1,386,145. Penalty average: Safe Work Australia, 1 September 2026. Fine: SafeWork SA judgements page, a 14 April 2026 conviction after an aircraft propeller injury. Undertakings: the term 3.6 tables, our median.

The two are not the same kind of dollar. A fine buys the duty holder nothing. Most of an undertaking buys the duty holder’s own equipment, training and systems, which it keeps.

If you are offered the option

It is not the cheap way out. The guidelines expect a commitment above and beyond what might occur if a prosecution were to take place, and the typical agreement here runs past $200,000 plus SafeWork SA’s costs, which ranged from $1,500 to $21,295 where an agreement entered them.

Fixing the hazard does not count toward it. Rectifications are listed but excluded, and some were large: one 2021 agreement reported $633,669.50 of them.

It is public for good. The signed agreement goes on the register with the incident set out. An EU does not constitute an admission of guilt by the person giving an undertaking in relation to the contravention. A breach of the agreement can bring a fine of up to $250,000 for a company, and SafeWork SA may go back to prosecuting the original matter.

Our read

This section is opinion, built on the documents cited above.

On the evidence of its own register, South Australia’s scheme mostly does what it says. Seventy-one cents in the dollar goes to the workplace where someone was hurt, and a scissor lift and a WHS manager will do more for the next apprentice than a fine paid into consolidated revenue. For a government department, an undertaking may be the only outcome that moves money from one place to another at all.

Two things would make it better. First, the community line should be tied to the hazard. A hand-safety course for Men’s Sheds after a hand injury passes that test; $60,000 for a football scoreboard after a fall from height does not, however good it is for the club. Second, SafeWork SA should publish a completion notice for each agreement, with what was actually spent. It already checks the invoices. Until it publishes the result, “$12 million spent” is a figure the public has to take on trust, and the register that should prove it can only show what was promised.

Methodology

We read SafeWork SA’s enforceable undertakings register on 16 November 2026 (40 entries, May 2015 to September 2026) and downloaded the signed agreement for each of the 25 accepted from June 2021 to September 2026, all on the current form. Three 2019 and 2020 agreements use the same form but fall outside the period; agreements before 2019 use an older form with no comparable total. For each we took the four lines of the term 3.6 minimum-spend table. Eleven of the 25 PDFs are image scans, which we converted to text by optical character recognition; every one of those tables adds to its own stated total, which is the check we relied on. One 2022 agreement states a total $2,845 below its four lines, exactly its regulator costs; two enter no regulator costs. Our $7,774,359 is the sum of the lines (the stated totals sum to $7,771,514). Shares are of the line sum. The median uses stated totals. Years are the month the register gives for each agreement. Counts of reasons, variations and completion notices are from the links the register lists under each entry. National penalty data are from Safe Work Australia’s 1 September 2026 release; the 2026 fines are SafeWork SA’s judgements page as read on 16 November 2026. Quotations are verbatim from the source linked beside them; the Department of Human Services quotation is from our text conversion of its scanned agreement, page 44.